Written and reviewed by Mark Battaglini, owner-operator of Rapid Response Handyman. Updated .
What Each Option Does
Rekeying changes the pins inside the existing cylinder so a new key works and old keys don't. The lock body, handle and finish stay. Replacing swaps the whole lockset or deadbolt.
Both solve the 'who still has a key' problem. The difference is whether the existing hardware is worth keeping.
Rekeying Makes Sense When
The hardware works smoothly, you like how it looks, and it's a lock that can be rekeyed.
- You just moved in or changed tenants
- A key was lost but the locks are in good shape
- You want several compatible locks on one key
Replacement Makes Sense When
The hardware itself is the problem, or you want something it can't do.
- The lock is worn, corroded or loose in the door
- You want a sturdier deadbolt or a smart lock
- Locks are mixed brands that can't be keyed alike
- The style or finish needs to change
A Practical Middle Ground
Many homes end up with a mix: rekey the good locks, replace the one that's failing, and key them all alike. A locksmith can usually tell within a few minutes which locks are worth keeping.
Next useful thing to know
- Sticking Doors & Worn Locks: Adjust, Repair or Replace?
- Repair or Replace a Door?
- When Should You Rekey Your Locks?
- Repair, Replace or Upgrade?
Local scope: Atlantic County and Cape May County. Find your town or neighborhood.
Bring the guide back to your property maintenance plan or compare repair and upgrade options.
Troubleshoot a specific problem
Service categories
Get this handled
Services in Atlantic & Cape May Counties related to this guide.
Service coverage includes Atlantic City, Egg Harbor Township, Mays Landing, Somers Point and across our South Jersey service areas.
